Oven Roasted Red Potatoes Recipe
Oven roasted red potatoes are the side I make when the main dish is already eating all my attention.
Cube the potatoes, top them with butter, onion salt and pepper, seal everything in a foil pouch, and the oven handles the rest in about 45 minutes. For more ideas to round out dinner, I keep a running list of side dish recipes.

Below is what goes in the foil pouch and how long to bake it, with the printable card at the end. Jump to the recipe
Why Baked Red Potatoes Work in a Foil Pouch
The foil traps the steam, so the potatoes cook in melted butter instead of drying out on a bare pan. Red potatoes have thin skins, which means no peeling, and small ones hold their shape once they are cubed.
This is one of those recipes you can start and walk away from while you get everything else together. Or, in my case, while I rush around trying to get the kids ready. These come out tender and buttery, not crispy, and my boys always counted them as comfort food.
How Many Potatoes to Make
The amounts bend easily to however many people you are feeding. If the potatoes are small, you can tell from the bag whether you have enough, because once they are cut up they take about the same space they do now. Use about a tablespoon of butter for every three small potatoes. I make smaller batches as a weeknight side all the time.

What You Need
Most of this is already in your kitchen. These are the ones people ask about, linked on Amazon:
- Onion salt, the seasoning that does most of the work here
- Ground black pepper
- Heavy duty aluminum foil, so the pouch does not tear when you shake it
- A rimmed baking sheet to carry the pouch in and out of the oven
Would you like to save this?
Shop My Kitchen:
These are the tools I reach for again and again in my own kitchen. I’m a Pampered Chef consultant, so links below may earn me commission at no additional cost to you.
Want to see more? Check out my favorite Pampered Chef products for busy kitchens and see which tools I use and recommend most.
Make It a Meal
Main dish: Hearty Ground Beef Casserole Recipes. These potatoes also go well with Trader Joe’s Orange Chicken on a night nobody wants to cook.
Vegetable side: Asparagus Spirals
Drink: Cotton Candy Mocktail
Dessert: Peppermint Espresso Cupcakes
If planning the whole week is the part you would rather skip, the Shortcut Supper Club sends the plan for you, and my 52 weeks of meal plans and shopping lists cover the rest of the year.
More Potato Recipes
- Loaded Twice Baked Potatoes
- Baked Sweet Potato Frittata
- Crockpot Potato Soup
- Chicken Potato Casserole
- Slow Cooker Sweet Potato Chicken
- Leftover Boiled Potato Recipes
- 25+ Sweet Potato Recipes
- Oven Steak Fries
- Oven Sweet Potato Steak Fries
Oven Roasted Red Potatoes FAQ

Oven Roasted Red Potatoes
Equipment
- Rimmed baking sheet
- Heavy duty aluminum foil
- Sharp knife and cutting board
Ingredients
- 3 lbs small red potatoes the smaller the better
- Cracked or ground black pepper to taste
- Onion salt to taste
- 1 stick of butter or margarine I prefer 1.5 sticks, but that is up to you
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 400 degrees
- Wash the potatoes thoroughly, then cut them into cubes no bigger than an inch. Put the potatoes on the NON-reflective side of the foil. Cut the butter into slices and put it on top of the potatoes. Season with onion, salt, and pepper as you like (I would take it easy, though everyone’s taste is different).
- Bring up the sides of the foil and roll them together, then do the same with the other sides. This should make a pouch that looks like this. Shake the pouch a little to distribute the seasonings and butter.
- Place the pouch on a cookie sheet and bake in the oven for 40-45 minutes. Open one end of the pouch VERY CAREFULLY because there will be a lot of steam, and it can burn you, and pour the potatoes into a bowl. You are done. Go have fun and watch everyone devour your potatoes!








