Everyone will go crazy for this Cookie Monster Fudge Recipe! That blue coloring with the edible eyeballs is so fun and creative! Fudge recipes like this are the best!

Adding the eyeballs with big cookie chunks takes the look and flavor to a new level. Give it a try today! You are going to love this tasty treat!

Blue cookie fudge squares with chocolate chips and candy eyes are stacked on a white plate, reminiscent of a Cookie Monster delight. Text in the center reads COOKIE FUDGE the perfect treat! The plate is set invitingly on a wooden surface.

If you’re a fan of fudge, this recipe will bring a smile to your face and happiness to your taste buds. The first bite definitely won’t be the last.

Table of Contents

Who says that making fudge has to be hard? You can easily mix the ingredients in a short amount of time – and have your very own batch of homemade fudge!

The best part about making fudge at home is having some leftovers to enjoy later. My boys love when I make fudge because they love to come back and eat pieces throughout the day!

This would be a super cute addition to baby showers, birthday parties, family gatherings, or even an afterschool snack!

A plate of Cookie Monster Fudge cubes, rich with cookie pieces and dotted with candy eyes, sits on a white plate. Labeled Monster Fudge, this easy recipe is sure to delight.

Why is my fudge not firming up?

If you’ve made fudge before, you know how frustrating it can be when it doesn’t firm up properly. There are several reasons why your fudge may not be set properly. Perhaps you didn’t cook it long enough, or maybe the temperature of your ingredients wasn’t quite right.

Another possibility is that you didn’t mix it enough, which can affect the consistency. It’s also important to note that environmental factors, like humidity, can affect the way your fudge sets up.

Luckily, there are ways to fix these issues and ensure that your fudge always comes out perfectly. Follow the recipe exactly, and you should be able to fix any issues!

By understanding the science behind fudge-making and addressing any potential problems, you can enjoy delicious, irresistible fudge that’s rich, creamy, and perfectly firm.

Specialty Ingredients:

The following ingredients are affiliate links on Amazon because they may be a bit hard to find in your normal store. I wanted you to be able to see exactly which things we are using.

Reminder, not all ingredients in the Blue Cookie Fudge Recipe are linked above, just the ones that may be a bit difficult to find or that you might be unsure of what to look for

🍳 My New Favorite — With a Reader Discount!

This is my new favorite nonstick skillet I use every single week — and I’ve got a deal just for you!

🛍️ Elite 5.5-Quart Oval Electric Skillet

✔️ Non-toxic & PFAS-free
✔️ Easy to clean (even after cheesy eggs!)
✔️ Beautiful enough to serve in

🌿 $25 off a $150+ purchase with code: 3BOYSANDADOG

Shop GreenPan – Save $25

🟢 “400+ readers clicked this code last month – I truly love this pan!”

Must Have Resources:

When making Cookie Monster Fudge at home, you really need to have the following Amazon affiliate tools on hand.

Make it a Meal:

Meal planning is a great way to save money and stress. If you’re ready to start, now is the time! Find out how simple and easy it is!

Main Dish: Hamburger Meat and Pasta Recipes

Would you like to save this?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later! You'll also get regular recipes & printables to your inbox!

Vegetable Side: Pan Fried Potatoes and Carrots Recipe

Starch Side: Southwestern Cheddar Steak Fries

Refreshing Drink: Pineapple Mint Spritzer Mocktail Recipe

A stack of vibrant blue fudge pieces with candy eyes sits on a wooden surface, resembling a fun Cookie Monster Fudge Recipe. The text reads MONSTER FUDGE sweet and delicious! Additional pieces temptingly await in the background on a white plate.

Best Fudge Recipes:

Once you make this Cookie Fudge Recipe, you will want to make more fudge! I’ve done the work for you and gathered some of my easiest fudge recipes!

This Raspberry Mermaid Fudge Recipe is so much fun to make!

Make a batch of this Crazy Good Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Fudge Recipe!

You have to give this Easy Oat Fudge Recipe a try!

Hot Fudge Sauce is a great dessert that can be added to many other desserts!

This Fudge and Peanut Butter Poke Cake Recipe is a must-make!

Check out the simple ingredients in this Delicious Egg Nog Fudge Recipe!

I love eating and making any of these 15+ Easter Fudge Recipes!

A stack of vibrant blue Cookie Monster Fudge pieces with chocolate chips and candy eyes sits on a wooden surface. More fudge pieces rest on a white plate in the background. The text above reads COOKIE FUDGE perfect for sharing!.

How do I store fudge?

Fudge is one of those sweets that feels indulgent and luxurious, making it a popular choice for gifts and special occasions. But a common question people ask is how to store fudge to keep it fresh and tasty.

The good news is that fudge can be stored relatively easily. The key is to keep it in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and strong odors. Storing the fudge in the fridge is a great way to keep it fresh.

An airtight container is also essential to prevent the fudge from drying out or getting stale.

This will help ensure your fudge stays delicious and creamy for as long as possible.