Skip to Content

Cookie Exchange Game Ideas

Sharing is caring!

Everyone loves a good Christmas cookie exchange! Have you ever been to one? They are loads of fun and are a perfect reason to get together with friends and family.

There are a lot of different ways to host a cookie exchange and there are always a ton of cookie recipes shared!

You can even turn your cookie exchange up a notch with some fun games. Make up some yummy cookie recipes and get started!

That’s right, just like any other party, you can encourage your guests to interact and enjoy themselves even more with these cookie exchange game ideas!

Games to play at your annual Christmas cookie exchange


Click Here for more Christmas Cookie Exchange Ideas including recipes, games, and invitations


Cookie Exchange Game Ideas:

Have a bake off!

Have your guests bake one cookie, that they would like to have judged, in a blind taste test! These cookie ballots from Simply Stacie make it super fun! Besides, what could be more fun than tasting ALL THE COOKIES!

Play Cookie Board Games!

You could play this cookie tic tac toe from Crystal and Co. or you could try a round of cookie checkers from The Mad Mommy! Play cookie backgammon or even use cookies as game money.

Make your own fortune cookies!

Using this tutorial from Red Ted Art, you can make your own paper fortune cookies! Customize them for your guests, make them funny or turn them into a fun DARE that your guests have to do!

Christmas Cookie Exchange Game Ideas

Enjoy Cookie Facials!

Set up your own cookie spa and include things like this gingerbread sugar scrub from Beauty Through Imperfection! It sounds luxuriously yummy.

Decorate Gingerbread Houses!

Release your inner child and have some fun with frosting and candy! Use this candy list from Oh, Honestly and you are sure to have some stunners! Use them to create a little village or award ribbons to your favorite ones!

Game Ideas for a Christmas Cookie Exchange Party

Whatever way you spin it and whatever cookie exchange game ideas that you use, just make sure you have fun!


Click Here for more Christmas Cookie Exchange Ideas including recipes, games, and invitations


Chat with friends and make new ones! Have fun moments with family members and start some new traditions!

Oh, and of course, leave with a full box of Christmas cookies!

Sharing is caring!


Tuesday 12th of December 2017

I like the fortune cookie idea! Sound so fun! Thank you for sharing on Merry Monday! Hope to see ya next week! Kim

Shelbee on the Edge

Monday 23rd of October 2017

I have never been to a cookie exchange, isn't that sad?! And now I am really hungry for some cookies! Thanks so much for sharing and for linking up with me On the Edge!